What size water heater for a family of 5?

For 5 people, water heater makers list a tank of 75–100 gallons (A. O. Smith, 5 people); 50–55 gallons (Rheem Manufacturing Company, 4-5 people); 75 gallons or tankless (Rheem Manufacturing Company, 5+ people); up to 80 (Rheem Manufacturing Company, 5+ people). The more exact way is the first-hour rating of your busiest hour. For example, if all 5 shower in the same hour and there is a shave and hand dishwashing, that hour takes 5 × 20 + 2 + 3 = 105 gallons, so look for a first-hour rating of at least 105 gallons; fewer showers in that hour need less.

Published tank sizes for 5 people

Tank size for a household of 5 as printed by water heater manufacturers, with the people range of each row
PublisherPeopleGallons
A. O. Smith575–100 gallons
Rheem Manufacturing Company4-550–55 gallons
Rheem Manufacturing Company5+75 gallons or tankless
Rheem Manufacturing Company5+up to 80

How to size a water heater for 5 people

Add up the hot water used in the busiest hour, by the U.S. Department of Energy figures: 20 gallons per shower, 2 per shave, 3 for hand dishwashing or food prep, 7 per dishwasher load. If all 5 shower in that hour, with a shave and hand dishwashing, it is 105 gallons; a tank's first-hour rating should be at least the total of your own busiest hour.

Tank or tankless

The first-hour rating, not the number of gallons in the tank, tells how much hot water a tank heater delivers in a busy hour. It is printed on the yellow EnergyGuide label, so compare models by it.

A tankless heater has no first-hour rating: it is sized by the flow of the fixtures that run at the same time and by how much it must warm the incoming water. The calculator sizes both.